
I was not asked to wear a Poppy at work this week, I was told to. For those of you not in the know, a paper Poppy is worn during the week of Remembrance in the United Kingdom in order to honour those who have served in the British military. The proceeds are then used to support war veterans and their families.
The question you are probably asking is, why would I not want to wear a Poppy in the first place? When I have told this story to several people, all except one have given me that answer. Surely I want to honour those who have died to defend this country and the freedoms and democracy we now enjoy.
Let's try again...I was TOLD to wear a Poppy at work this week.
It goes a little deeper than that actually. The reason I was told to wear one was not because any of the managerial staff felt it was fitting, it was because a company called Body Care was not allowing their staff to wear their Poppies in work, as they were not part of the uniform. Heaven forbid anyone should confuse Body Care with The Body Shop, and ask if the reason I was not wearing a Poppy was because I had been told I couldn't wear one. That would be awful. That would...make for a decline in sales! Which is deeply undemocratic.
I confess to having a stubborn streak. When I am told to do something, I want to know why. I want a good reason. Be it believing in God, wearing a certain dress code or not being allowed into somewhere. I don't see this as unusually as others do. Some people think I just like to cause trouble, that I should put my head down and go with the flow.
But here's the thing. If they'd put their head down and gone with the flow, black people would still have to drink from separate fountains. Gay people would be in jail or internment camps. Women would still be tied to the kitchen, not allowed to vote. The Aztecs thought the Spanish invaders were gods, so they put their heads down and worshipped, and look where that got them.
When I bring forth my views about why I don't wear a Poppy, I'm looked at in shock like I'm some kind of monster. Surely these freedoms that men have died defending include the right to not wear a Poppy? There's something deeply hypocritical about these "freedom" we live in, this post 9/11 crusade where you must have an American flag on your porch and a Poppy on your lapel or otherwise you're some sort of traitorous extremist.
Lest we forget. Lest we forget, most of the young men were sent to war against their will, and the ones who simply wanted peace were sent to jail and humiliated with white feathers. Lest we forget, an eye was turned when children signed up to military service, lying about their age. Lest we forget, Britain turned the other eye when stories about the horrors at Auschwitz were brought to the country. Lest we forget, it was the Soviet troops who discovered the concentration camps and freed the Jews.
Lest we forget, whole families were torn apart for the sake of sending fodder to the front lines.
Lest we forget, we have a government who sends people to war, and then relies on a charity to take care of them when and if they come home, because they're too busy spending our money sending more people to war and buying even more weapons.
There's this idea that if we don't fight and kill, we'll suddenly be taken over by the threat from "outside". There is no alternative to this, nobody is seeking an alternative to this and there's a perfectly good reason why. It is not because war works so well. If war worked perfectly, there would only have been one many years ago and none since then. It is because war is a wonderful business. It sells papers and missiles and battle armour, it sells guns and bombs to either side. Yet again, lest we forget, the Taliban were trained by the USA as a way of fighting against the Soviets. That one didn't quite work out very well did it.
It's always weird to me when we talk about soldiers being killed in war with so much surprise. It is certainly upsetting, and I don't discount the emotion of it. It is an incredible waste. But...when you sign up to run with the bulls in Pamplona you expect to get trampled. You might wrap it up in defending civil liberties but when you sign up with the Army you are going out to be trained to kill, and there is a ridiculously high chance you are going to be killed in return. We see a soldier and we are expected to feel proud, but that man or woman is carrying a gun, and that gun is full of bullets and those bullets are going to rip through someone's vital organs.
I bet there are people completely willing to rip my head off for the statements I am making. I know this because like no other subject, I have had people scream at me for talking this way. How dare I. Who do I think I am. I am disrespectful and uncaring of our troops. This is a lie. I care about our troops so much, I want them to come home and not die. I want them to never have to fight a war again. I want them reunited with their families, and given a job where they are not threatened with death and injury and murder on a daily basis. I know, I'm a complete monster.
Why is it so controversial to talk about not agreeing to war? I hate this view people have whereby they spout "if it wasn't for our brave troops, we'd all be speaking German now". I am not siding with Germany here, I am not some form of Nazi sympathiser but it seems like there are only these two extremes when it comes to talking about any war. You are either with us, or against us. A lover of freedom or a dirty Muslim. Now get that bloody Poppy on your chest and raise your arm in salute...oh wait, I got a little confused there for a moment.











